Medical TV shows have long been a source of entertainment, drawing viewers into the fast-paced world of health care centers and the lives of the providers who work there. Among the many emergency medicine dramas that have graced our screens, there’s a constant question: which one is the most realistic? Let’s check out the contenders – “ER,” “Grey’s Anatomy,” “Code Black,” “St. Elsewhere,” and “Chicago Med” – to determine which comes closest to capturing the true essence of emergency medicine.
5. Grey’s Anatomy
At the bottom of our realism scale is “Grey’s Anatomy” (2005-present). While undoubtedly popular, the show’s focus on melodrama and soap opera elements often overshadows its portrayal of medical cases. “Grey’s Anatomy” has been criticized for its improbable scenarios and medical inaccuracies, detracting from its credibility as a realistic depiction of emergency medicine. Check out this Time magazine review for more.
4. St. Elsewhere
“St. Elsewhere” (1982-1988) follows closely behind. St. Elsewhere isn’t exclusively focused on the ED but it does feature in many episodes. While its focus on interpersonal dynamics among staff adds depth to its storytelling, many feel “St. Elsewhere” lacks the medical accuracy and production quality of more modern series. At the same time, “St. Elsewhere” took on many important medical issues of the day including provider drug abuse, AIDS, gender transitions, and others. Regardless of its medical accuracy, critics argue that the show had an undeniable impact on other medical dramas to come. Check out this Washington Post perspective.
3. Chicago Med
Next, we have “Chicago Med” (2015-present). Part of the “Chicago” franchise created by Dick Wolf, the show offers a balanced mix of medical cases and personal storylines. While “Chicago Med” has been praised for its attention to detail and diverse cast of characters, reviews vary about how accurate the show really is. A TV Insider review claims “Chicago Med” is 85% medically accurate while others pan the show completely – thus it’s ranking in the middle of the realism pack here.
2. Code Black
Moving up the realism scale, we encounter “Code Black” (2015-2018), inspired by the documentary of the same name. Set in the busiest ER in the nation, the show emphasizes resource constraints and high patient volumes faced by providers in a public hospital. “Code Black” earned praise for its gritty realism and attention to medical detail. Many reviewers put it towards the top of the list for its realistic portrayal of emergency medicine. Check out this article from MedPage Today that reviews “Code Black”and a number of other medical shows.
1. ER
And the most realistic emergency medicine show is…”ER” (1994-2009), a groundbreaking series that revolutionized the medical drama genre. Set in a busy Chicago hospital, “ER” is celebrated for its fast-paced storytelling, dynamic characters, and unparalleled medical realism. The show’s attention to detail, with medical consultants ensuring accuracy in procedures and terminology, sets it apart as the most realistic portrayal of emergency medicine on television. Read more about ER and its creator writer (and M.D.) Michael Crighton here.
Recap
Each emergency medicine TV show brings its own unique perspective to the genre, with varying degrees of realism and authenticity. While “ER” stands out for many as a benchmark for accuracy and attention to detail, other shows offer valuable insights into the challenges faced by emergency medicine providers – and none of them are perfect. Whether it’s the intense drama of “Code Black,” the groundbreaking topics covered by “St. Elsewhere,” or the character-driven narratives of “Grey’s Anatomy” and “Chicago Med,” viewers can find entertainment and inspiration in the diverse portrayals of life in the ED.
Responses